Attorney General Eric Holder stunned and disappointed many conservative lawyers with his decree that state attorneys general have no obligation to defend state laws, or even state Constitutions, that define marriage as the union of one man and one woman. Many attorneys general, and certainly most Republicans, believe it is precisely their duty to defend their state’s laws and constitution, whatever their personal feelings about a particular issue.
Not Holder, who told the National Association of Attorneys General in Washington on Tuesday that they have a higher mission than enforcing the law. “The essential duty to which all of us, as attorneys general, have been sworn,” he said, is “not just to win cases, but to see that justice is done.” State laws and constitutions that define marriage as one man and one woman are discriminatory, Holder continued, and do not deserve the attorneys generals’ defense, because the AGs’ duty is “not merely to use our legal system to settle disputes and punish those who have done wrong, but to answer the kinds of fundamental questions — about fairness and equality — that have always determined who we are and who we aspire to be, both as a nation and as a people.”