Whether or not one believes that America is suffering a crisis of runaway judicial activism, there is at least a broad consensus on this point: The Supreme Court led by Chief Justice William Rehnquist has significantly weakened the protections enjoyed by criminal suspects and convicted prisoners. This widely accepted view is spread by journalists and liberal legal interest groups, both of whom seem genuinely convinced of it. But is it so?
A review of recent decisions reveals a court with more kinship to Judge Harold Baer than Judge Roy Bean. Since Rehnquist became chief, the court not only has refused to overturn any of the major Warren-court decisions establishing new criminals’ rights. It has affirmed every one of these rights that has come before it. Indeed, it has actually expanded some rights, if only in a gradual and somewhat arcane manner.