With the real estate market already reeling, Congress would be foolish to do anything that would further drive down property values. It would be even worse to do so while also mounting a wholesale assault on private property rights. But that’s what would be done by the misnamed Clean Water Restoration Act sponsored by Rep. James Oberstar, D-MN. Oberstar’s proposal is so bad it ought to be permanently buried six feet under dry land.
The Constitution gives Congress the power to regulate “interstate commerce.” The original 1972 Clean Water Act expands that power to regulation of any “navigable waters,” with the regulatory authority given to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Little by little, the Corps expanded its reach, so that it soon was not just maintaining navigability but also enforcing environmental regulations – and then enforcing them not just on navigable interstate waters, but on ponds connected by ditches to streamsthat led into navigable waters. But when the Corps absurdly started trying to regulate low-lying land that sometimes developed puddles that might overflow into those ditches, property-rights activists fought back. In 2006, the activists earned a partial Supreme Court victory with a decision re-stating that private land is, indeed, not a navigable waterway used for interstate commerce.