With the Iowa Caucus looming closer, there is one day left to see if Hillary Clinton will repeat the mistakes of 2008 or emerge victorious against Bernie Sanders. If young people have much to say about it though, Hillary is likely to lose.
In perfect timing then, or at least obvious timing, the Huffington Post late Saturday morning published a sort of last-minute effort to generate support from Hillary supporter Peter D. Rosenstein, who writes “To Students and Millennials: Take Another Look at Hillary Clinton.”
Recommended Stories
This isn’t Rosenstein’s first attempt. Eight days ago, The Huffington Post published a similar piece, “Why Hillary Is The Right Choice for Iowans, and Bernie Sanders Isn’t.”
With all the scandals there are surrounding Hillary, and possibly more to dig up, it’s worth wondering if Rosenstein really wants young people to take that closer look. More pressing though is how desperate his attempt seems. More one, there’s so much emphasis it’s almost cringe worthy. But, there is the substance to consider as well.
Rosenstein’s very first paragraph is a partisan one:
Right, okay. Good to know it’s Republicans who “have been stymied by the truth,” not the two people who have hidden emails and silenced rape victims.
He next goes into endorsements, which Rosenstein passionately disclaims are the “establishment,” no matter what Bernie Sanders and others say. He gins up the support and endorsements she has gotten from pro-LGBT groups, for instance, which is also likely to defend Hillary from those who have pointed out how she’s been against same-sex marriage in the past. That point is not explicitly mentioned though.
Rosenstein also provides a rich perspective on how he views certain issues. There’s the mention of “groups representing women.” He then goes on to say that, with original emphasis, “women’s organizations providing needed healthcare to poor women including NARAL and Planned Parenthood endorsed her.”
Did a spokesperson from either of those groups write that for Rosenstein? Planned Parenthood may be a taxpayer funded organization, but its facilities are also outweighed by Federally Qualified Health Centers 20:1. Planned Parenthood is also the nation’s largest abortion provider, and, like Hillary Clinton, advocates for abortion until the moment of birth. NARAL likewise does the same. If such advocating counts as “providing needed healthcare to poor women,” then Rosenstein has quite the narrow view of issues.
Back to endorsements though. When it comes down to the members of the establishment who have endorsed Hillary? It’s because “they trust Hillary can get the things she says she wants to do done.”
Rosenstein’s millennial appeal for Hillary is basically summed up with:
Remember that cringe worthy emphasis? Oh, it’s coming. For Rosenstein lays it out with:
- “Do hundreds of endorsements for Hillary prove Sanders is the anti- establishment candidate? The answer to that is NO!“
- “The facts!” have to do with Bernie Sanders being the establishment candidate, which really amounts to a hit job on his involvement with the NRA
- “The truth!” involves Hillary’s support for the Affordable Care Act
- “It is part of the system our forefathers (a shame there were no foremothers) set up allowing us to move the nation forward to become as the preamble to our constitution said, ‘a more perfect union‘.”
- “When he became President, [Obama] trusted Hillary enough to name her Secretary of State.”
- Obama thinks Hillary is “‘wicked smart.‘”
Rosenstein also pulls a page from Debbie Wasserman Schultz ill-fated and unpopular book. Though he refrains from calling young women “complacent,” he pretty much makes a similar point:
At least in this paragraph, Rosenstein is willing to mention abortion. But his categorization of Planned Parenthood and NARAL were a stretch at best. If he’s really trying to appeal to millennials and students, he may want to remember that millennials are pro-life, and that Students for Life of America groups outnumber Planned Parenthood.
After a while, the piece not only becomes irrelevant to students and millennials (if it was ever). In closing Rosenstein writes:
It’s just all that much more tiring and unreadable. Rosenstein supports Hillary, we get it. And you should too, especially if you like being explained to how wonderful and amazing and terrific Hillary is.