Harvard law prof: Originalist interpretation would make Cruz ineligible

Published



[caption id=”attachment_155510″ align=”aligncenter” width=”3875″](AP Photo/John Locher)

[/caption]

It’s the birther controversy all over again, this time to do with Ted Cruz and the Republican Party. And just like Hillary Clinton had started the birther movement against then rival Barack Obama, the trouble comes from Cruz’s own party.

Whether or not it’s an actual issue for Cruz, it doesn’t take a scholar to see why it’s become so recently relevant. The claims are the latest attack from Donald Trump. The two candidates were once quite friendly with each other, even embracing at a rally in September against the Iran nuclear deal. But, as Trump has made it well known, he has a problem with people when they start to poll better than him. Hence the attacks on Cruz’s eligibility now that he is beating Trump in Iowa.

To make his claim, Trump cited Harvard law professor Laurence Tribe, who taught Cruz as well as Obama and many Supreme Court justices. The Guardian was in contact with Tribe, who lamented “that’s really sad.”

Work that is fair and well-produced should know no political affiliation. But, what may be “really sad” would be if Trump is using Tribe’s name to further his own political agenda to remain the front-runner at all costs.

The Guardian noted that:

“Despite Sen[ator] Cruz’s repeated statements that the legal/constitutional issues around whether he’s a natural-born citizen are clear and settled,” he told the Guardian by email, “the truth is that they’re murky and unsettled.”

…

In his emails to the Guardian, Tribe discussed Cruz’s own approach to constitutional issues, noting that under “the kind of judge Cruz says he admires and would appoint to the supreme court – an ‘originalist’ who claims to be bound by the historical meaning of the constitution’s terms at the time of their adoption – Cruz wouldn’t be eligible because the legal principles that prevailed in the 1780s and 90s required that someone be born on US soil to be a ‘natural born’ citizen.”

He added: “Even having two US parents wouldn’t suffice for a genuine originalist. And having just an American mother, as Cruz did, would clearly have been insufficient at a time that made patrilineal descent decisive.

Also according to Tribe, “there is no single, settled answer.” The issue may be further complicated in how he also noted “our supreme court has never addressed the issue.”

In addition to pointing out an originalist stance from Cruz which some may view as ironic, Tribe made a case for a living, breathing Constitution. He argued that “…to the kind of judge that I admire and Cruz abhors – a ‘living constitutionalist’ who believes that the Constitution’s meaning evolves with the needs of the time – Cruz would ironically be eligible because it no longer makes sense to be bound by so narrow and strict a definition.”

Time, and perhaps even a court case, will decide if Cruz’s status of natural-born citizen is an issue for him to become president. If it matters to the voters, the Iowa caucus, where Cruz is ahead of Trump, is only three weeks away.