Cheers & Jeers » Can’t go wrong with Kobe or LeBron

Published



A few days ago Phoenix’s Shaquille O’Neal told a Cleveland reporter that Kobe Bryant was a 10 and LeBron James a 9.7 — or, he said, maybe a 9.8. Another NBA executive told us privately that he loves Bryant over James; always has and probably always will.

That should settle it, right?

Not quite. Here’s the second part of what O’Neal said and it’s why James, at least for one of us, is the guy we’d want to build a team around. And it’s why we think, at the midway point, he’s the MVP of the league.

“He’s a fabulous player who does it the right way and gets everybody involved,” O’Neal said of James. “Those guys [Cavaliers] are playing at a very, very high level right now because of him.”

And here’s what our executive said, “Take LeBron off that team and there is a tremendous dropoff to the point where it is arguable if they are higher than the eighth seed in the East.”

And that’s what an MVP does; he lifts the level of play of those around him. Mo Williams was not an All-Star before he came to Cleveland (though it took two injuries and an awakening from David Stern to make him one). But Pau Gasol was an All-Star before joining the Lakers last season.

There’s no doubt Bryant is an awesome player and if someone says he’s the best then they could make a good argument. But James is the MVP because he defines valuable. He’s quick enough to cover guards, such as Bryant. He’s strong enough to cover centers, as he does when the Cavs go small. His defensive improvement is quite noticeable.

Their big games in New York illustrate the differences between the two. Regardless if James had a triple-double or not, he ended up with 52 points and 11 assists. So he accounted for at least 74 points; maybe much more given that some certainly came on three’s.

Bryant scored 61 points, but had just three assists. Bryant — whose rings were won with O’Neal — is a killer player. He’s like Tiger Woods on the back nine of a major. Don’t bet against him.

But if we’re starting a team, we want someone who can do everything. We want a superstar who trusts his teammates. That’s LeBron.