Is Boehner double counting spending cuts?

Published



This morning, House Speaker John Boehner announced that, because he has so far failed to reach a deal with President Obama to avert the so-called fiscal cliff, he would proceed with a “Plan B.” Under this approach, Boehner will move a bill in the House of Representatives later this week that will make permanent current income tax rates for everybody earning under $1 million. It will not address the automatic cuts to Medicare and defense as a result of the sequester, or unemployment benefits, or any of the other non-tax items that have been part of fiscal cliff talks.

Boehner’s advancement of the “Plan B” option is not likely to represent an end point in the fiscal cliff chess match, but more likely, just his latest maneuver. So that’s why it’s still important to keep in mind something else Boehner said — that he supports a “balanced approach” in which $1 trillion in tax hikes are traded for $1 trillion in spending cuts, while Obama’s offer raised taxes by $1.3 trillion and only cut spending by $850 billion. But the important question to ask is, how is he measuring spending cuts? More specifically, is he measuring spending cuts beyond those that were already scheduled to go into effect automatically? Or, is he measuring spending cuts assuming the sequester gets averted? Because if it’s the latter, then the actual dollar amount of spending cuts being discussed could be a lot lower than $850 billion or $1 trillion. And if, under these circumstances, Boehner did offer Obama a one-year extension of the debt limit, it would also mean that he’s double counting the same spending cuts to offset two different debt limit hikes. Let’s just review the history.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.