If you don’t know about the Simon-Ehrlich bet, go here to read up on it. The quick version is that rational optimist Julian Simon bet ‘genius’ doomsayer Paul Ehrlich that the price of certain commodities that Ehrlich was worried that mankind was using up would go down, not up, in reflection of Simon’s belief that human welfare was increasing, not decreasing as Ehrlich insisted. Simon won. Earlier this year, the New York Times’ resident optimist John Tierney won a similar bet with the late peak oil theorist Matthew Simmons. Now, peak oiler David Murphy says that Simon and Tierney’s wins were just the result of dumb luck.
My boss, Fred Smith, read Murphy’s post and commented, with his usual insight:
Recommended Stories
Print subscriber? Click here to login/register your account
Digital subscriber? Click here to login/register your account.