Hundreds of congregations across the country have left the Episcopal Church (TEC) over the past decade, moved to act over the church’s evolving doctrine on sexuality. The tipping point for many was after the church ordained Gene Robinson, its first openly gay bishop, in 2003. One of those congregations was the Falls Church Anglican in the Virginia suburbs of Washington, which voted to realign with the conservative Convocation of Anglicans in North America in 2007. But more than six years later, the Falls Church Anglican remains locked in a legal battle with its old church in a case that’s made its way to the Supreme Court—and may have consequences for the relationship between civil law and church law.
Following the congregation’s break, TEC demanded that the Falls Church Anglican trustees transfer its property to the church’s diocesan bishop, per canon law. When the congregation refused, TEC sued the Falls Church Anglican and the 10 other congregations in Virginia that departed.