Let’s have separation of campaign and the state

Published



Speech regulators of the campaign finance “reform” movement are nothing if not relentless, and in the wake of the failure of McCain-Feingold, they’re back with new and bigger plans to “clean up politics.” Now they want to force taxpayers to fund all federal political campaigns.

Advocates of the recently introduced Fair Elections Now Act, led by Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin, seek to ban contributions from lobbyists, limit other sources of campaign funds and provide matching taxpayer funds to candidates who raise qualifying contributions. Home-state contributors would be limited to giving $100.

As with previous efforts, the self-anointed reformers are trotting out alarmist rhetoric and platitudes to advance their arguments. “People are following the money, [and] money has been a corrosive influence in Washington,” says Common Cause President Bob Edgar, a former congressman who, apparently being better than other congressmen, somehow survived the experience untainted.

Despite the enthusiasm for taxpayer funded political campaigns by so-called reformers, however, voters aren’t swooning to pay for billboards and 30 second negative ads; in 2006 10.9 percent of Americans opted to fund the presidential system (a drop from 28.7 percent in 1980). There’s no reason to believe voters will give greater support to handouts to congressional candidates.                                         

There is no evidence that these schemes have had an impact in reducing lobbyist and interest group influence or producing better government, which are the main arguments advanced by supporters.

Interest groups in “clean elections” states leverage their organizational strength — mailing lists, phone banks, staff and volunteers — to assist candidates in raising qualifying contributions that lead to tens or hundreds of thousands or even millions of taxpayer dollars.

 Former Arizona Gov. Janet Napolitano accepted the help of organized labor in her campaign, and they responded by raising a quarter of the 4,000 small contributions she needed to receive millions of dollars in taxpayer dollars.

Candidates are just as grateful to an interest group that aids them in this manner as they are to donors who give money directly. A study by the Center for Competitive Politics found that most small donors in New Jersey’s pilot program (discontinued last year) were members of a handful of interest groups. Claims that ‘clean elections’ will restrain the growth of government, promote a more diverse legislature, or add to competition have also been found wanting in the states that have chosen that route.

Subsidizing politicians with taxpayer dollars fails because it is based on a fundamentally flawed premise: the belief that lobbyists or campaign contributors somehow represent “special interests” that frustrate some objective political interest of the common American.

The problem is that the common American or the “public interest” does not exist. We are a diverse nation of seemingly infinite interests. These competing views often clash in Congress, which decides whose policy prescriptions will prevail.

There are average Americans on both sides. The First Amendment protects the right of citizens and their representatives (usually called “lobbyists”) to petition government, and for citizens, through donations to campaigns, to join together in support of candidates who share their principles.

In the TARP and in government ordered firing of General Motors CEO Rick Wagoner, we have seen how government control of financing is followed by government control of substance. Whether this is good economics we will leave to others, it’s surely bad politics.

 Far from subsidizing campaigns, we should insist on separation of campaign and state. When the government funds these campaigns it fundamentally alters the relation between citizens and the government. Criticism and change are no longer a right, but a grace granted by the government.

Taxpayer financing of campaigns has been tried in several states and in presidential races for over three decades and has failed to deliver the promised benefits. It places the government in the position of regulating and controlling the very speech and political activity intended to change the government and its policies. It’s an idea that should be put to rest once and for all.

Former FEC Chairman Bradley Smith is Professor of Law at Capital University Law School and Chairman of the Center for Competitive Politics. Jeff Patch is Communications Director at the Center for Competitive Politics.

 

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.