Everyone has an opinion on the firing of 241 District of Columbia teachers as a result of Schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee’s Impact evaluation system. An additional 737 teachers, found “minimally effective,” will be terminated if their performance doesn’t improve within a year.
But this issue, like many others in education, is not a “black and white” one. I am not familiar with Impact, but the performance evaluations I saw in my 23 years with Fairfax County Public Schools were deeply flawed: by turns rigorous or pro forma, based on outside evaluations during the merit pay years, and based on principals’ recommendations all the other years. There were rarely surprises: What the principal thought of you was clear right from the beginning, and the observation reports rarely ventured into new territory.