“There is no argument among medical professionals — pediatricians, pediatric endocrinologists, adolescent medicine physicians, adolescent psychiatrists, psychologists, etc. — about the value and the importance of gender-affirming care,” U.S. Assistant Secretary for Health Rachel Levine told NPR recently. This was Levine’s way of saying that it is actually harmful not to gender-transition boys into being girls and vice versa, even though that often means permanent mutilation of a child’s body and irreversible hormonal treatments.
With the assertion that there is “no argument,” Levine is using a fallacy called “proof by assertion” — as if the forceful repetition of a controversial statement can make it true. This is a concerted effort by the Biden administration and the gender-transition industry to quell a raging debate among medical professionals and researchers, many of whom strongly disagree. It requires the most tendentious interpretation of the available scientific evidence to assert that it is helpful to administer puberty blockers, hormone treatments, or surgery to children — or even to believe that those are genuinely “affirming” forms of care as Levine described it.