People with a stake in the nuclear energy debate are seizing on events in Japan. It’s unfortunate, really, because the event really isn’t over yet.
But the debate has already cranked up. And it usually shakes out like this:
- Nuclear energy good overall: We should not let this derail the renaissance.
- Nuclear energy bad overall: We need to look to favored energy source X.
“We” in such statements usually means “government.”
But what few people are saying is Japan’s earthquake illustrates why we need a much freer energy market.
So I’m going to say it.
It’s true. In certain areas earthquakes are black swan events like that described by Nicolas Taleb — extremely rare, but in some sense inevitable over time. We might quibble about the state of geological science — which, if better understood, might make such swans “‘grayer” (meaning more predictable) — especially in places like Japan where such disasters are more commonplace. But let me not get too far from my fundamental point.
An unsubsidized energy market, coupled with a robust system of common law, gives energy companies incentives to gather better “local knowledge” about natural disaster risks. Sounds wonky I know, but let me break it down: