Some Good Advice from the Field for Gen. Petraeus

Published



Gen. David Petraeus is getting lots of advice from all quarters–public and private, wanted and unwanted, helpful and unhelpful. This, from Jason Thomas, an Australian just returned from eight months working on the civilian side of the counterinsurgency effort in Afghanistan, was recommended to me by experts I respect as one of the best contributions. Read the whole thing at the estimable Small Wars Journal website, but here are the highlights:

“My brief advice would be to suggest five changes that may help turn the tide in Afghanistan – but they require a paradigm shift in how our political leaders decide troops should engage and how aid organisations and civilian policy makers place moral judgements on development.

1. Change Coalition Forces rules of engagement – it’s not about troop numbers it’s what the troops do – Yes, counterinsurgency is about winning the population not blazing your way through the enemy.  But Pashtuns and Hazarans are tough, resilient and stoic people and the coalition loses all respect when it does not engage the enemy when under continued attack….

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.