The debate will rage from here on out. That is, if it hasn’t already been decided. And by most accounts, the title of GOAT already has been bestowed upon Roger Federer.
Does he deserve it?
Recommended Stories
Based on his accomplishments, you have to say yes. Federer now has won 14 Grand Slam events, tying Pete Sampras for the most ever. But Sampras never solved the French Open and never even reached the final — and only one semifinal. That merits calling Federer the greatest men’s tennis player of all time.
However, one strike against Federer is the era in which he’s played. Others, like the 1980s, were more competitive with Ivan Lendl, Jimmy Connors and John McEnroe.
One Web site wondered how Federer would have fared against this group. Maybe he would not have had 14 titles; maybe it would have been around eight or nine. But the others also would have had fewer. And that still would have made Federer the best of arguably the toughest era.
One reason there haven’t been more challengers, aside from Rafael Nadal, in this period is because of Federer. The same has been said of Tiger Woods. It was even said once about Michael Jordan.
Greatness tends to beat down others, making them seem ordinary. Like Federer, that’s what Rod Laver did in the 1960s, winning the Grand Slam as both an amateur and a professional. He lasted seven straight years as the No. 1-ranked player.
Everyone wants to crown someone as the greatest ever, always assuming the present is the best. If you want to put him down in that spot, we’ll endorse the selection. But do us a favor: use a pencil.