Nats rotation for last 2 months of 2010

Published



Given the Nats began the year with about a dozen candidates to either make the Opening Day starting rotation or see time on the mound at some point in 2010 the chaotic mess they have on their hands now is no surprise. No, the rotation hasn’t been terrible. It just has way too many moving parts. Think we need an exercise to keep everyone straight. So here it is — what you can expect over the final two months of the season from the starting pitchers.

Stephen Strasburg is set to go tomorrow against the Marlins. The Nats’ fondest hope is that their 22-year-old prized rookie makes it through the rest of this season without any of the recurring shoulder soreness that sent him to the disabled list. Other than that – just keep doing what you’re doing kid. We’re looking at nine starts so far with a 5-2 record and a 2.32 ERA, 75 strikeouts and 15 walks. Can’t ask for much more than that – except just stay healthy and get to spring training ready to be a staff ace for a full season. Any slight twinge in that shoulder, though, and Strasburg is done for the season.

Livan Hernandez has been everything the Nats could have wanted – a 35-year-old veteran who found the fountain of youth and became a reliable presence at the top of the rotation. Oh, you were expecting a 3.03 ERA? Be serious. The last time Livo posted an ERA under 4.00 was in 2005 with the Nats in their memorable first year in Washington – and that was a 3.98. Amazing. 

Now come the questions. Is Scott Olsen healthy for good? He’s made just 10 starts in 2010 with recurring shoulder soreness. He’s also flashed some signs – especially early – of being a pretty good mid-rotation piece. His ERA is at 4.12 after a sub-par outing against the Diamondbacks last week where he gave up two homers. It was also just his second start since May 21. Let’s cut Olsen some slack, see how his shoulder handles the final two months and evaluate every start closely. After all, the Nats non-tendered Olsen last season after his injury issues and then re-signed him anyway. Is he part of the spring-training mix in 2011 or will the organization deem him unreliable thanks to that spotty injury history and move on to other options?

It’s just about a lost season for Jason Marquis, the 31-year-old veteran. Elbow surgery in May put him on the shelf for months. He was shelled prior to that. He was ineffective during his return against the Dodgers on Sunday with four runs allowed in an ugly first inning. Again, it was his first healthy start in a while so give the guy a break. But Marquis — signed to a two-year, $15 million contract last winter that looks worse by the day — needs to show something down the stretch. Fact is, there’s plenty of competition heading into spring training next year. The Nats could use a serviceable veteran whose biggest strength was his durability. Marquis was supposed to be that guy. Can he bounce back from injury fast enough to prove he still is? And even if he doesn’t can the Nats really eat $7.5 million? To be honest — that kind of cash doesn’t taste all that great.

It’s also been a lost season for Ross Detwiler. The sixth pick in the 2007 draft missed three months after hip surgery. But he looked great during his minor-league rehab stints this summer and appeared ready to use the final two months as an audition for a rotation spot in 2011. Yeah – not so much. He wasn’t any good in his first start against Milwaukee on short rest, pitched a nice game against the Phillies and then his defense let him down in Arizona. Now Detwiler’s back on the disabled list with hip soreness related to the surgery. Hopefully it’s just a minor setback. But even a best-case scenario means a late August return. That would still get Detwiler four or five starts to finish the year and get him close to 70 innings total between the minors and the majors. That’s not much, though. The front office would have liked a better idea of where one of its better young arms stands at this point. 

John Lannan is healthy. He’s also pitching for his job. The Opening Day starter — a reliable member of the rotation for two full seasons — probably won’t see his ugly numbers recover from a rough start to the year. He spent over a month in Double-A trying to work out his problems. So far, so good — 11 innings against the Phillies and Dodgers, four earned runs. He’s stayed away from the walks (three), which just kill a contact pitcher like Lannan. But he only has five strikeouts. This is what he is. If Lannan finds his form — keep the ball near the strike zone and make them hit in on the ground – he has value. If he doesn’t there are plenty of other candidates ready to pass him on the depth chart.

Now, the mystery man. Yunesky Maya is a 28-year-old Cuban signed by Washington last month. He is in Viera, Fla., working his way back into pitching shape. He’ll make his first minor-league start this week and you should see him in Washington by the end of the month. To be honest — who knows what the Nats have here? Maya has looked good in international tournaments. He’s not a flamethrower, but appears to understand how to exploit a hitters’ weaknesses. He’s dominated a level of baseball that Johnny DiPuglia, Washington’s director of international scouting, describes as “somewhere between Double-A and Triple-A.” Maya will be here by Sept. 1, for sure, and get some time to learn National League hitters. By spring training the Nats will have a better idea of where he slots in a big-league rotation.

It’s only a matter of time for Jordan Zimmermann. His progress back from Tommy John surgery has been remarkable — so quick the Nats have even backed him off just to give his right elbow the full 12 months to heal. He could be three minor-league starts away from heading back to the big leagues. Zimmermann showed such promise last year as one of the organization’s best young arms. I’d expect some pretty uneven results over the last six weeks. But all the Nats care about is that Zimmermann’s velocity is good – he sat in the low 90s pre-injury with the ability to hit 95 when he had to — and that his mechanics come back. His rehab starts have been routinely excellent. This is the piece Washington wants to pair with Strasburg next season and beyond.

As for Craig Stammen — there’s just no room at the inn. The organization has long looked at the 26-year-old as a possible weapon out of the bullpen. His velocity would play well there. For now, he settles into long relief. The timing is ironic, though. Stammen’s last four starts have been pretty good — even if he needed some luck to get out of trouble a couple of times against Arizona last week in a 7-2 win. But versatility is key and if Stammen shows he can handle that role he’ll have a fallback spot next spring if a starting job isn’t in the cards.

Okay, so we also know J.D. Martin (back) is on the 60-day disabled list and done for the year with surgery on a herniated disc upcoming. Luis Atilano (elbow) is rehabbing, but seems headed for minor surgery, too. Matt Chico (6-6, 3.88 ERA) and Shairon Martis (7-6, 4.09 ERA) have had nice seasons at Triple-A Syracuse, but it’s hard to see either getting a shot at a September call-up barring further injuries or setbacks. As for veteran Chien-Ming Wang, Nats general manager Mike Rizzo has repeatedly said he expects to see Wang sometime in September. I guess I’ll believe that when I see it. Wang has been throwing pitches off the mound in Viera, Fla., but we haven’t heard a specific date for a rehab start, yet, either. Until that happens Wang will remain on the periphery. He’s also under team control for another year so why push it just to get him a start or two at the end of September?

Follow me on Twitter @bmcnally14