With regard to treatment of suspected terrorist detainees held by the U.S. military at Guantanamo Bay, let’s get this straight: It wasn’t torture. And it absolutely wasn’t criminal. Last week, six Republican members of the Senate Armed Services Committee released a statement defending the “honorable public service” of American officials excoriated in public commentaries based on a Dec. 11 committee report on detainee interrogation methods. The six GOPers said Pentagon and Justice Department officials were being criticized despite having used appropriate procedures, amidst major ongoing terrorist threats, in reviewing and approving interrogation techniques. Where they may have erred, they did so in good faith and they then took great pains to correct errors. Critics calling for criminal charges against former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and other administration officials are thus divorced from reality. Consider the facts. Two months after 9/11, Pentagon General Counsel William J. Haynes asked whether “enhanced” interrogation tactics might help gain information useful against terrorism, and which ones were legal. Surely those were appropriate questions as part of the aggressive efforts to save thousands of American lives. Then in August 2002, the Department of Justice ? the controlling authority on these issues ? issued two memos advising that numerous forms of stressful techniques were legal. At the same time, U.S. officers at Guantanamo were requesting guidance. Based on the Justice memos, Rumsfeld in December tentatively approved a Haynes recommendation that all but three of the methods reviewed be used. None of the techniques included “waterboarding,” or anything remotely approaching it.
Print subscriber? Click here to login/register your account
Digital subscriber? Click here to login/register your account.