Postseason play doesn’t equal greatness

Published



If winning in the postseason is how we determine elite players, then the Pro Football Hall of Fame ineeds to build another wing.

Where else will the busts go for fluke Super Bowl Most Valuable Players such as quarterback Mark Rypien, kick returner Desmond Howard or safety Dexter Jackson?

The reason those players aren’t among the game’s all-time elite is because they failed to continually play at a high level throughout the regular season.

The key to greatness is finding players who can excel through the grind of a 16-game schedule. Their fantastic production for five months is the reason their team makes the playoffs. That’s why the NFL is right to hand out its awards at the conclusion of the regular season and not take into account postseason performances.

Atlanta quarterback Matt Ryan may be at home watching the playoffs, but there’s no doubt he played a bigger role in his team’s success than Joe Flacco.

Ryan not only had to erase the bad karma of Michael Vick, but was counted on to win games the day he was drafted. He delivered –and that’s why he’s the Offensive Rookie of the Year. Flacco, who was named the starter by default in the preseason, became the first rookie to win two playoff games, but Ryan did more to get his team into the postseason. Ryan was 4-2 in games decided by four points or less, compared to Flacco, who was 0-3.

Under the logic Flacco deserves the award over Ryan because he advanced further in the playoffs, then former Redskins running back Timmy Smith should have earned the award for his 204-yard, two-touchdown performance in a 42-10 win over Denver in Super Bowl XXII.

Under the logic Flacco deserves the award over Ryan because he advanced further in the playoffs, then former Redskins running back Timmy Smith should have earned the award for his 204-yard, two-touchdown performance in a 42-10 win over Denver in Super Bowl XXII.

Smith’s career lasted just four years and he gained about as many career rushing yards as days he spent in jail for dealing cocaine.

At the halfway point of the regular season, many experts thought they had their Offensive MVP: Cardinals quarterback Kurt Warner.

But he struggled to maintain his play at a high level until the end of the year, and was benched in a 47-7 loss at New England. He threw six interceptions in his final five games in the regular season.

Even eight games isn’t enough to determine who are the best players in the league. So who deserved the award?

The player who won it: Colts quarterback Peyton Manning.

Many say Warner, who plays in the NFC Championship Game this afternoon, still was the best. But Manning led his team to a 12-4 record with an offense that was among the worst at running the football. The Colts lost in the first round at San Diego in overtime, but if it wasn’t for Manning’s stellar play during the regular season, his team wouldn’t even have made the playoffs.

One fewer win, and New England would have taken the Colts’ place in California.

The final chapter of a book might be the most exciting, but it wouldn’t have the same drama or suspense if the story wasn’t solid from page one.