How many times have voters heard someone say or write that candidates are too socially conservative or too religious to win?
This latest argument comes from Luke Brinker for Mic, who writes that “Marco Rubio Has a Strategy to Win the Primary–But Could It Cost Him the General?”
Recommended Stories
Brinker likely thinks that his piece is rather insightful and original. And, the first part of it actually makes some good points. But he should have also quit while he was ahead. Brinker explains Rubio’s campaign strategy to not so much win Iowa (remember, Donald Trump is still in the race), but to come in third, behind Cruz, or even second. He could then ride that to finishing second in N.H.
In his opening paragraph, Brinker even mentions that Democrats have “express[ed] fear that his nomination could spell trouble for frontrunner Hillary Clinton.” But the rest of his piece seems to suggest that that could all change because Rubio is a social conservative and a religious man.
Now, why Brinker sees that working in Iowa is because it fits the Christian, socially conservative electorate. Sure, fair point. But, Rubio himself is also genuinely a Christian and a social conservative. It’s a campaign strategy, but it’s also who Rubio is.
Also mentioned in the opening paragraph is how Rubio has “been hailed as “the Republican savior,” the party’s answer to President Barack Obama — a charismatic, transformational figure who can revive the GOP’s national fortunes.” That cover seems to follow Rubio, including to Thursday’s GOP debate, in which he addressed being regarded as any kind of a “savior.”
Brinker also references a “Faith” ad that Rubio aired in January and takes note about another ad, which he regards as similar:
“A government incredibly out of touch, and millions with traditional values branded bigots and haters,” Rubio said in the ad. He didn’t explicitly mention same-sex marriage, but for Iowa’s Christian conservatives, his meaning was clear.
The “meaning is clear” not just for “Iowa’s Christian conservatives,” though but to any Christian who has experienced being “branded bigots and haters” for their “traditional values.”
Rubio has mentioned faith plenty of other times as well. He had a noteworthy conversation with an atheist and has openly spoken about his faith to many other voters.
Now there’s some ranting against Rubio’s traditional and anti-abortion views, especially how it pertains to millennials. Brinker does not admit that he is referencing such views with regards to millennials because Rubio may be the GOP’s best shot to win such a demographic, a point which even the Huffington Post conceded to, somewhat.
That millennials are in favor of same-sex marriage is a valid point, but they are a pro-life generation, a point most other media outlets, even pro-abortion and liberal ones, will admit. Drinker tries to claim that ” 55% favor some degree of abortion rights, according to the Public Religion Research Institute.” The poll results are not as specific as they ought to be, and conflict with many polls on millennials and abortion.
In asking, with original emphasis, “Does it hurt him?,” Brinker notes that “the risk for Rubio is that in finding a way to win the GOP primaries, he’ll render himself less formidable in the general election.” In the next paragraph he warns that “moderate voters in crucial swing states, who may favor conservative economic prescriptions but lean to the left on social issues, could also balk at a Rubio candidacy.”
It is worth noting the lessons from history, as recently as 2012. Mitt Romney was certainly a qualified candidate, but he ignored social conservative issues. He lost, in part because social conservatives stayed home.
It’s also asking what the real solution is then? For Rubio to become less religious and less socially conservative, and thus less of the person that he is? That will certainly go over well with voters.