At the beginning of the year, President Trump’s ticket to reelection was simple. While voters still disliked Trump on a personal level, all he had to do was appeal to the ways in which they liked Trump’s America: the lowest unemployment in a half-century tightening the job market so real wages grew for the first time in a decade (disproportionately in favor of minorities and women), some foreign policy victories, and the slow steps to dismantle the anti-growth regulatory bureaucracy thanks to Republican judicial appointees.
Half a year, a pandemic, and a summer of riots later, the calculus is much different. After posting record personal satisfaction and economic confidence at the beginning of the year, voters now overwhelmingly believe the nation is on the wrong track. Trump can no longer campaign on what has happened under his presidency and must make an affirmative case of what will happen if given the chance of a second term. But Trump has utterly failed to change the single most damaging dynamic of the race for his odds: namely that the overwhelming majority of voters are motivated by how they feel about him, not Democratic nominee Joe Biden.