In a recent report subtly titled “Secret Spending in the States,” the Brennan Center for Justice argues that “exceptionally tough disclosure requirements and [an] active enforcement culture” can help extirpate the scourge of “dark money” in state and local politics. This is either Pollyannish naivete that underestimates the threat of harassment and its chilling effect on speech, or fully ripened duplicity that counts on it.
The First Amendment guarantees your right to join with others to advance your point of view. As part of this guarantee, the First Amendment protects your right to keep your participation private. In the 1958 case NAACP v. Alabama, the Supreme Court held that Alabama could not force the NAACP to disclose its members: “Inviolability of privacy in group association may in many circumstances be indispensable to preservation of freedom of association, particularly where a group espouses dissident beliefs.” Perhaps the staffers at the Brennan Center are unaware that their position on “dark” money would once have found a home with the segregationists of the Jim Crow South.