The Smiley Gonzalez/Carlos David Alvarez Lugo affair is the latest black eye for the Nationals and embattled general manager Jim Bowden.
It may prove to be one embarrassing episode too many for a franchise that can’t afford any more public relations hits.
Recommended Stories
Team president Stan Kasten was noncommittal during a news conference last week as the FBI investigation into the skimming of bonus money from Dominican prospects continues.
But the minuses have certainly begun to overwhelm the pluses with Bowden, who multiple baseball officials said last summer has strained relations with some peers. San Diego general manager Kevin Towers once publicly said in a radio interview there was just one general manager he wouldn’t deal with:
“Jim Bowden,” Towers said. “The guy’s an idiot. I won’t take his calls, and I don’t think many others do.”
Now, that hasn’t stopped Bowden from making deals. And a legitimate argument can be made that Bowden has done the best he could with the pieces in place when the Lerner family took over ownership from Major League Baseball.
He traded for promising young outfielders Lastings Milledge and Elijah Dukes. He did the same for pitcher Scott Olsen and outfielder Josh Willingham this winter. Bowden was chastised for refusing to deal Alfonso Soriano at the 2006 trade deadline. But one of the two draft picks the Nats received when Soriano left turned into second-round pick Jordan Zimmermann, who is the team’s top prospect, according to Baseball America, and in contention for a rotation spot. And the Nats’ finances — with an estimated $55 million payroll and $20 million in contracts coming off the books this winter — are actually in good shape.
But for all the good there is still Bowden’s reputation, which precedes him. And also the DUI charge in 2006. And now a Dominican prospect debacle that — even if uninvolved, as Bowden claims — at the very least occurred on his watch. Maybe Bowden skates away unscathed when the investigation concludes. But the ice is getting awfully thin.
The organization doesn’t need more embarrassments. It needs a GM who avoids the spotlight, something Bowden hasn’t yet accomplished. It’s easy to ignore it when a club is winning. The Nats aren’t winning.