Why it’s rational for Republicans to oppose EPA

Published



One of the political writers I have most admired over the years is Ronald Brownstein, now of the National Journal, which also publishes The Almanac of American Politics of which I am co-author. But his latest piece, on Republican opposition to the Obama administration Environmental Protection Agency, comes in well below his usual mark. It is headlined “Curious cohesion: Why are Republicans from competitive districts supporting efforts to weaken antipollution regulations?” The theme is that House Republicans in the current Congress have voted almost unanimously to overturn and otherwise disapprove or limit EPA regulations, while many Republicans, particularly from coastal areas (he mentions the Northeast, but he could have added Florida, which has had the second or third largest House Republican delegation during much of this period) in the 104th and later Congresses elected starting in 1994 supported EPA measures.

Brownstein’s implications, left unarticulated, run something like this. Today’s Republicans are more ideological or subservient to their leadership or anti-environmental restriction interests than many Republicans in the 1990s. Today’s Republicans, especially in those in Democratic-leaning districts (he uses the benchmark of whether a district voted for Barack Obama in 2008), are taking grave political risks by voting against EPA measures. Finally, today’s EPA regulations have the same putative validity of those in the 1990s.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.