NO ALTERNATIVE

Published



I am no longer hip. The agency of my discovery was a radio station that specializes in “alternative” rock: An abrasive song by some angry grunge band came on during a drive, and I immediately punched to a classical-music station. Only a few years earlier I had been on the rock ‘n’ roll cutting edge, but now I prefer soul, classical jazz, zydeco, even big band — anything but the sound of screeching young men with their flying guitars.

On the way home, I stopped at a bookstore and picked up The Spin Alternative Record Guide by the writers and editors of Spin magazine. If I was going to give up the hipster ghost, I needed a sign that “alternative” music, the music that defines 90s cool, no longer spoke to me. Reading the $ ISpin guide makes it obvious that “alternative” rock isn’t really about music at all. The editors claim that “just as, generationally, baby busters have found it difficult to distinguish their identities from boomers — no war protests, no indisputable defining experiences — alternative rock lacks the proud boundaries that rock’s original tradition kept so well guarded.” Despite this disclaimer, the editors nonetheless make a stab at a definition by way of comparison with baby-boomer, or “old-style,” rock:

 

More than jazz, blues, country, or any other musical genre, old-style rock was defined by a mass appeal you didn’t have to sneer at, the mythic popularity of the universal youth music that turned the repressed fifties into the rebellious sixties. . . . Alternative rock, on the other hand, is anti- generationally dystopian, subculturally, presuming fragmentation: it’s built on an often neurotic discomfort over massified culture, takes as its archetype bohemia far more than youth, and never expects that its popular appeal, such as it is, will have much of a social impact.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.