Under Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA)–a plan implemented in 2012 by the Obama administration to protect children who entered the country illegally with their parents–undocumented students subsequently earned access to public higher education. As of now, 21 states offer these students in-state tuition. It is possible that, in the near future, Georgia will join that number.
On Oct. 15, the 39 undocumented Georgia students took their pleas for lowered tuition to the Georgia Supreme Court.
Recommended Stories
In past months, the plaintiffs in the case have attempted to sue the Board of Regents for in-state-tuition. However, the verdict after hearings in both the Fulton County Superior Court and the Georgia Court of Appeals, was that the Board of Regents is protected from such a lawsuit based on sovereign immunity.
This ruling of sovereign immunity was the focal point of the Oct. 15 hearing. If the Georgia Supreme Court rules the plaintiff does has a case, then the lawsuit and following hearings will be thrown back to the Georgia Superior Court for the final decision.
Even if the high court does decide that the lawsuit cannot stand against sovereign immunity, the fight for these undocumented students to receive lower tuition is anything but over.
The argument for in-state tuition for undocumented students in states such as Georgia, Arizona, and Indiana specifically has come under national scrutiny in recent days.
In the first Democratic presidential debate, Hillary Clinton was questioned about her stance on in-state tuition for undocumented students. In support of states who already have in-state tuition for all, Clinton said, “My plan would support any state that takes that position, and I would work with and encourage other states to do the same thing.” Both Sanders and O’Malley have touted a similar, though much more aggressive, platform on the issue.
Though lowering tuition for all undocumented students may seem like the reasonable thing to do on surface level, its damaging effects on legal citizens are undeniable. Opponents argue that these public benefits for illegal aliens are unfair to taxpayers.
What many politicians—such as Clinton, Sanders, and O’Malley—seem to miss in their argument that all residents of a state deserve the same in-state tuition, is that it’s not simply “residential” status that grants people lowered tuition. It’s taxpayer status. State taxpayers have fed into the University System of Georgia for years, and their reward is a lower price of college for themselves and for their children.
Opponents of the lowered tuition bills, despite national criticism, have stuck to their mantra that lowered tuition for undocumented students is costly and unfair to legal, taxpaying citizens. The state of Georgia’s decision in the upcoming months has potential to set a precedent for other states to follow. It will be interesting to see whether that precedent falls in favor of the undocumented student, or sways to uphold in-state tuition as a privilege for legal citizens.