Whether or not tonight’s debate will influence voters in South Carolina is unclear, but if it does, it should provide a boost to Newt Gingrich. On several occasions, on a wide range of issues, Gingrich had a solid and energetic debate performance. In what’s likely to be the defining moment of the debate, he had a strong pushback when asked by Juan Williams about his comments about President Obama being a “food stamp president,” arguing about the importance of people finding jobs. But he also had other strong answers — on Social Security and on prosecuting the War on Terror.
Mitt Romney, normally unflappable in these debates, was quite shaky tonight. Rick Santorum, early on, challenged him on ads attacking his position on allowing felons who had served their time to vote. Romney struggled to stake out a clear position on the issue, before settling on being against voting rights for violent felons who served their time — but then Santorum noted that he did nothing to change the policy as governor of Massachusetts. Even worse for Romney, he couldn’t give a straight answer on whether or not he’d release his tax returns. He said he “probably” would in April, but added qualifiers such as “time will tell,” whatever that means. This is problematic, because it’ll undercut Republicans attacks on Obama’s lack of transparency if Romney is the nominee and refuses to release his tax returns.