Cheers & Jeers » Staying, going, thinking

Published



Our top three college players who made a good choice by turning pro:

1. WR Darrius Heyward-Bey, Maryland » The Terrapins won’t play in a New Year’s Day game next year and his stock is as high as it will ever go after amassing 609 yards and six touchdowns.

2. QB Matthew Stafford, Georgia » The prototypical pro quarterback has nothing left to prove in college. He threw for 3,459 yards and 25 touchdowns last season.

3. WR Hakeem Nicks, North Carolina » His stock couldn’t be higher after catching eight passes for 217 yards and three touchdowns in the Meineke Care Car Bowl.

And now our top three college players who made a bad choice by turning pro:

1. RB P.J. Hill, Wisconsin » A product of a run-heavy offense; averaged less than five yards per carry and is a suspect receiver.

2. QB Josh Freeman, Kansas State » The quarterback-heavy Big 12 will be lighter next season, especially in the North Division. He is no better than the fifth-best player at his position.

3. RB Donald Brown, Connecticut » A rusher who lacks top-end speed needs to prove himself for more than one year. More than 2,000 yards and 18 touchdowns is nice, but it came in the Big East.

Top three undecided players:

1. RB LeSean McCoy, Pitt » His ability to make plays after the catch is always attractive to pro scouts and his young age (20) makes him even more of a commodity.

VERDICT » GO PRO

2. QB Sam Bradford, Oklahoma » If he can’t make plays against an SEC defense, what will he do in the NFL? He needs one more year, even if it is spent lighting up the Big 12.

VERDICT » STAY

3. QB Mark Sanchez, USC » After shredding Penn State in the Rose Bowl and leading the Trojans to another Pac-10 title, he has done it all. Well, almost. Still …

VERDICT » GO PRO