Justice Antonin Scalia was a man who drew strong reactions. Many strongly disliked his views and interpretation of the Constitution.
Though many quickly turned to the politics of nominating Scalia’s replacement, most people from all sides of the political aisle still managed to be respectful.
Recommended Stories
But, there are those who are part of the angry, extremist, left-wing. Some call themselves journalists. For The Root, Kirsten West Savali can’t even hold back in her lack of disrespect in her title, as she writes “Call a Thing a Thing: Scalia’s Judicial Terrorism Should Not Be Celebrated.”
The left-wing here is not only in this case angry and extreme, but intolerant.
Savali’s tribute starts off by mentioning Scalia was “racist, charismatic, misogynist, intelligent, homoantagonistic, witty, a good friend and a judicial terrorist.”
She even claims that she “didn’t cheer Scalia’s death.” But, in the same sentence she presents conspiracy theories as the truth and writes that “I fully understand the catharsis many people experienced when the news was announced that he was found dead in his bed with a pillow over his head…” Her piece should be discredited for the fact alone that it furthers conspiracy theories.
Quite the claims are made about the man:
And for that, Scalia is “a bigot.”
But, because he is “a bigot,” Scalia provides Savali an outlet for spewing pent up anger. Savali uses his death to rant against and relate “the Scalia narrative” to:
- “Texas textbooks defining the peculiar institution of slavery as migrant work…”
- “White supremacist mechanisms that have people calling Martin passive and Malcolm violent.”
- Abraham Lincoln being regarded as the “Great Emancipator.”
- Claims that the Black Panther Party hates white people
- Thomas Jefferson
- the belief that the “United States flag, waving gently over the genocide of black, brown and indigenous people, is pristine.”
And yet Savali is the one to say “we don’t have time for sociopolitical distortions and half-truths.”
Savali closes with her “sincere condolences… to Antonin Scalia’s friends and family.” In the same paragraph as evoking this man’s family, she with much more sincerity, writes her “solidarity goes to those who realize that there is one less white supremacist in the world lynching our humanity not with a rope and tree, but with a robe and bench, all in the name of justice.”
Savali prides herself on the idea to “make it plain and get it right.” Her bio lauds “provocative commentary.” And the very first words of her title say “Call a Thing a Thing.” Her piece is provocative all right, it’s not polite and it’s not welcomed. That doesn’t mean it’s thoughtful journalism though. And who’s to say this rant’s not the same thing, or worse, as cheering his death.