What constitutes a “black” story? If the novelist, screenwriter, or director behind the story is black, is that sufficient? If the characters are of African descent, is that good enough? Or are there certain requisite elements in terms of setting, plot, dialect, and the moral character of the protagonists that ultimately determine the answer? And, if there are, what becomes of a black author who’d rather write a retelling of Aeschylus than a story about urban drug dealers and teenage mothers?
Cord Jefferson’s 2023 Oscar-winning American Fiction, now streaming on Amazon Prime, deliberately refrains from providing all the answers to these questions. However, like Percival Everett’s 2001 novel Erasure, on which the film is based, it definitely has a lot of fun exploring them.