When a federal district judge ruled on March 1 that President Donald Trump could not remove the head of the Office of Special Counsel, Hampton Dellinger, it seemed like a huge setback for the administration. In a 67-page opinion, Judge Amy Berman Jackson stressed that Congress had made that whistleblower-protection agency independent of presidential control because it could not otherwise perform its function of preventing and policing corruption in the executive branch. Several days later, the District of Columbia Circuit Court of Appeals lifted that injunction pending appeal, leading Dellinger to drop his lawsuit and accept his dismissal.
Similar legal challenges are continuing, but the legal resistance to the second Trump administration should be careful what it wishes for because district court rulings are inevitably appealed and the buck always stops with the Supreme Court. The justices had already declined to intervene in Dellinger v. Bessent without any ruling on the merits because, at that point, Jackson had only entered a temporary restraining order that was about to expire anyway, but the writing is increasingly on the wall. As Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote in dissent from his colleagues’ nonaction, federal courts’ “equitable remedies” (such as injunctions) are limited to those available when the Judiciary Act of 1789 was passed and that by 1888, it was “well settled that a court of equity has no jurisdiction over the appointment and removal of public officers.”