Restoring America

Conservative values, National renewal

The legacy of Ellis Island is a legacy of assimilation

Published



Although immigrants today are more assimilated into American culture than previous generations, they could still be more integrated. And contrary to what many on the Left argue, assimilation benefits not only immigrants but also the native-born by boosting job prospects, personal satisfaction, and social cohesion.

Many believe those who immigrated to Ellis Island were poor, illiterate Europeans who against all odds succeeded. But the Ellis Island narrative is misleading. While early 20th-century immigrants were poor by today’s standards, they were positively selected relative to their home countries — often better educated, healthier, and taller. That’s partly because coming to America was expensive, so the very poorest didn’t make the cut. Once here, there were no federal welfare programs before the New Deal. Immigrants who couldn’t make it simply went home. Those who stayed did so because they succeeded.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.