Most Americans assume that if you commit a serious crime, you’ll likely face consequences. The reality is starkly different. Even for the most serious crime — murder — the national clearance rate hovers around 55%. That means if you kill someone, it’s essentially a coin flip whether you’ll ever face charges. For other violent crimes like robbery, the clearance rate is less than 30% — and this only considers crimes that are reported to police (many are not). By the time you get to property crimes, the odds of getting away with it are even higher. If you steal a car, break into someone’s home, or shoplift, the chances you’ll be arrested are vanishingly small.
Recent months have seen reformers claim that murder rates are at historic lows and violent crime is falling. Meanwhile, President Donald Trump says current rates of violent crime are unacceptably high. (They’re both right: Violent crime is lower than it used to be, and it is still far too high.) This debate predictably focuses on whether and how long to lock offenders up once they are caught. But it misses a much bigger public safety issue — one that both sides should agree is a problem: how rarely serious offenders are caught in the first place.