The news is decidedly mixed regarding the nation’s most notorious “judicial hellholes” — described by the American Tort Reform Association as the worst jurisdictions in which to get sued. On one hand, the watchdog group downgraded Madison County, Ill. — once the nation’s top venue for questionable class-action lawsuits — after a series of reforms sparked by public outrage greatly reduced court shopping there. Unfortunately, two more judicial hellholes — in Clark County, Nev., and Atlantic County, N.J. — have stepped in to take its place. These developments were spotlighted yesterday as ATRA released the 2007 edition of its memorably titled compilation.
The District of Columbia got a well-deserved “Dishonorable Mention” for a widely ridiculed case involving former administrative law judge Roy Pearson, who sued a D.C. dry cleaners for $54 million over a pair of lost trousers. The case dragged on for two years and cost the defendants $240,000 in legal fees before it was finally dismissed in a two-day trial.