The Vatican’s Nativity scene drew praise, laughs, and condemnation after Pope Francis inaugurated the display over the weekend.
The nontraditional set was designed by students and teachers at an art school in Castelli, Italy, according to CNN. The town is part of the Abruzzo region and is known for producing ceramics.
“It is not what we expected, and not what most of us want,” started a Catholic Herald opinion article headlined, “The Vatican’s Embarrassing SciFi Creche.” “This year’s Vatican creche has been laughed at and ridiculed for looking like a science fiction story or children’s toys.”
This installment took 10 years to create, according to Vatican News, and was completed in 1975. The set comprises 52 different pieces, including life-size ceramic statues.
The pope praised the work in his Friday address, calling the set a sign from God “in the midst of the suffering of the pandemic.”
“Never as in this year have they been a sign of hope for Romans and for the pilgrims who are able to come to admire them,” he said.
Twitter users quickly commented on the set. Catholic Herald contributor Tim Stanley called the scene “absolutely terrifying.”
It is absolutely terrifying.
— Tim Stanley (@timothy_stanley) December 11, 2020
Others criticized the unusual display for lacking the comfort of a “familiar and traditional” set.
“At a time when people around the world have anxiety over the future … it would have been comforting to see a Nativity scene which is familiar and traditional,” conservative commentator Tanya Granic Allen tweeted. “But they went with this.”
At a time when people around the world have anxiety over the future, when many Masses have been cancelled, and churches closed- it would have been comforting to see a Nativity scene which is familiar and traditional. But they went with this. #vaticannativity https://t.co/KPf8ZkOCBU
— Tanya Granic Allen (@TGranicAllen) December 14, 2020
Fox News contributor Raymond Arroyo called it “worse than advertised.”
“Is that Baby Yoda emerging from the Fisher-Price space man figurine?” he asked.
The Vatican Nativity is worse than advertised. Is that Baby Yoda emerging from the Fisher-Price space man figurine? https://t.co/wC9eGRs06E
— Raymond Arroyo (@RaymondArroyo) December 11, 2020
Others, however, were more receptive.
This year’s scene is not the first nontraditional set to grace the Vatican’s plaza. In 2018, sculptors created a 5-meter-tall sculpture out of more than 700 tons of sand that covered 25 square meters — though without any spacemen.
2018 Vatican Nativity scene. Just amazing. Carved out of sand brought in from near Venice. pic.twitter.com/rAC2yejNZV
— Rob MacKay (@mackayrob) December 10, 2018