Manhattan Moment: Courts shouldn’t ignore due process to create class actions

Published



Wal-Mart v. Dukes, a case claiming job discrimination against at least 1.5 million women, reached the Supreme Court last week after the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco agreed, in a 6-5 vote, to permit the case to go forward as a single class-action. The press is portraying this as a dispute over how “large” a class action can be, but that is incorrect. There is nothing inherently wrong with a large class action. A class action is simply a procedural device meant to aggregate similar claims for purposes of efficiency. Thus, while it may not make sense for a single individual to bring a lawsuit about an illegal $20 overcharge in a phone bill, if you bring together 2 million people with identical phone contracts and overcharges subject to the same law, one can try the claims in a single case.

The trial over Amy’s phone bill will be the same as the trial of Zachary’s phone bill, so it’s possible to have a single trial to resolve the issues of all 2 million phone bills, with the class represented by a handful of representative plaintiffs. A class of 2 million would be even a larger class than that of the Dukes case, but it wouldn’t be any more controversial than any other class action.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.