Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Director Richard Cordray evidently is feeling unfamiliar heat after resorting to a disreputable form of sophistry as a substitute for honest discussion and debate. During a June 10 hearing of the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee, for example, Cordray responded to a question from Sen. Mike Johanns, R-Neb., on the ballooning cost of CFPB’s headquarters renovation by saying: “This has been out there and taken as gospel in the public record for some time. It’s a fiction of the Washington Examiner that this project started out at $55 million and now has ballooned to higher proportions. There never was any expectation that this project could be completed for $55 million. That is false.”
Cordray, the former Ohio Attorney General, was straw-manning, an evasion tactic known and loved by professional politicians, double-talking bureaucrats and courtroom sophists everywhere. Instead of answering a question truthfully, the fast-talking practitioner erects a straw man that is easily demolished. In this case, the straw man is Cordray’s invention of a mythical claim by the Examiner that “this project could be completed for $55 million.” Simply put, the Examiner never made that claim.