Policy differences are no reason to lose your head

Published



On one side of Capitol Hill, Senate Judiciary Committee Republicans dropped their opposition Wednesday to attorney general nominee Eric Holder after Holder privately pledged not to prosecute officials from President Bush’s administration who were involved in interrogation of terrorist detainees. On the other side of the Capitol two days earlier, the House Judiciary Committee subpoenaed former Bush aide Karl Rove to testify on a variety of policy issues and decisions. Nowhere in all of this political maneuvering was there any clear statement that mere policy differences should never serve as a pretext for inflicting partisan vengeance.

The idea of prosecuting those who crafted or implemented Bush administration terrorist interrogation policies, for instance, should never have come up even as a suggestion, much less as a bargaining point on the Holder nomination. Those who participated in the interrogations did so in good faith under difficult and unprecedented circumstances. Even the liberal columnist Richard Cohen of The Washington Post wrote last week that “it is imperative that our intelligence agents not have to fear that a sincere effort will result in being hauled before some congressional committee or a grand jury.” Or being thrown in jail for trying to protect America.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.