I thought I was critical of the Obama administration’s Libya policy (policies?) in my Wednesday Examiner column headlined “The damning contradictions of Obama’s attack on Libya.” But my criticisms were muted and pallid next to those of the normally sober Adam Garfinkle, editor of The American Interest, who writes that “the Obama administration has definitively gone down the rabbit hole.” Lest you miss the analogy, he explains, “Like Alice with her pills, some things are getting or will soon get bigger—risks, mission definition and casualty figures on the ground in Libya—while others are getting smaller—our reservoir of good options, our stock of common sense and our peace of mind. I do not invoke Lewis Carroll lightly. I do so in this case for a special reason: words we thought we all understood have now become encrusted with bizarre new meanings, or no meanings at all, as if our vocabulary has been hexed by Humpty Dumpty himself.” Scorcho! Time to get out your collected Orwell and reread his classic essay “Politics and the English Language.”
You get a similar message, with a lighter touch, from Michael Kinsley’s Los Angeles Times column on the subject. “Wait a minute,” he begins. “How did this happen?” Kinsley points up many of the problems with the administration’s approach and, uncharacteristically, concludes with an alternative policy of his own. “Was there nothing we could have done between sitting on our hands and launching something close to all-out war? Sure there was. We could’ve done what we did for Eastern Europe, which helped bring victory in the Cold War: verbal support and financial support for dissidents and democrats. Make clear which side we’re on, but without overpromising. It sounds like the opposite of ‘Speak softly and carry a big stick,’ and in a way, it is. But it worked to defeat communism, and our track record with bigger ambitions in smaller situations has not been impressive.”