It’s September now, which means that, a mere year and a half after the beginning of the presidential campaign (ugh), it’s finally almost debate season. The first debate will be held tonight (September 26), the rest in October, and if previous elections are any indication, one of them will focus lopsidedly on the rest of the world.
The foreign policy debate has historically produced some memorable moments, like Mitt Romney’s claim that Russia is America’s greatest adversary, dismissed contemptuously by President Obama at the time but seemingly more prophetic today. This year’s contest could be especially weighty, since Donald Trump has taken unorthodox positions on everything from NATO to nation building. So what should the moderators ask the candidates? Here are a few suggestions.
Recommended Stories
Under President Obama, American troops are back fighting in Iraq. What’s your plan for an endgame in that country?
This is no small matter. Obama has been surreptitiously ramping up our troop presence in Iraq for months now. The White House now acknowledges we have at least 5,000 pairs of boots on the ground and our artillery units have engaged ISIS, despite an agreement with the Iraqi government that forbids us from deploying more than 3,870 troops. How the Iraqi army is supposed to take command of their own country when they’re wholly dependent on American air and ground power (as well as Iranian-funded militias) is unclear.
Thirteen years after the invasion, Iraq remains a mess. What has this taught you about nation building?
Iraq’s economy is a shambles, its government is paralyzed, its sectarian divisions are pronounced, violence is commonplace, and ISIS controls swaths of the country. Widespread unemployment, courtesy of plunging oil prices and corruption, has made young Iraqi men susceptible to the rhetoric of terrorism. Meanwhile, Iran exerts significant influence. This is not how it was supposed to be, yet we continue trying to nation build, in Libya and now in Syria. Surely, there’s a lesson to be had here.
Does our current military action against ISIS require congressional authorization? Why or why not?
America is currently engaging the Islamic State in at least three different countries: Iraq, Syria, and Libya. It’s doing so on the legal basis of the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF), that yellowed piece of parchment passed by Congress shortly after 9/11. But that AUMF only allows war against those who “planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001, or harbored such organizations or persons,” which doesn’t cover ISIS. America’s current war is thus extra-constitutional; it must be either approved by Congress or abandoned.
President’s Obama position is that the Syrian Civil War is a quagmire, and if Russia and Iran want to sink into it, that’s their prerogative. How involved would America be in Syria under your presidency?
Few things in life are more futile than betting on the Syrian Civil War. That labyrinthine conflict has placed Russian and American forces much too close to each other; endangered American relations with Turkey, which is currently attacking the Kurds we’re backing; and seen al-Qaeda reemerge as a fearsome power player. American weapon shipments to the so-called moderate rebels have proven unfeasible, and sometimes ended up in the hands of ISIS and al-Qaeda. It’s not all bad — our bombs have helped roll back the Islamic State — but is there really a bigger role for us to play in this impenetrable tangle?
Are you going to contain or accommodate a rising China?
Ask most foreign policy experts what the West’s most daunting international challenge is, and they’ll tell you it isn’t even close. China is everything: The world’s most populous country and second-largest economy, rising quickly but propelled by volatile markets, sitting near crucial allies Australia and Japan, as well as rogue state North Korea, our number two trading partner, our number one foreign creditor. Beijing is flexing its muscles in the South China Sea, which is integral for international commerce. Its claims over tiny islets there will become a major global security issue going forward.
Can President Obama’s nuclear deal contain or deter a nuclear Iran? Or will we need some form of military action?
The verdict is still out on whether President Obama’s nuclear agreement with Iran will be a success. On one hand, the IAEA informs us that Iran is compliant and has been disarmed of much of its nuclear infrastructure. On the other hand, hardline Islamists continue to be belligerent, menacing our ships in the Persian Gulf and testing ballistic missiles. What we do know is that the Obama administration sold the deal dishonestly and concealed several subsequent developments, including the now-infamous $400 million payment to Tehran. If the agreement is to win public support, the next president needs to be more transparent.
Would you request a new round of BRAC hearings, to close bases that are unneeded by the military?
If you’ve seen House of Cards, you know BRAC hearings are a great way to get screwed by an ambitious power couple. But in the real world another round of BRAC — it stands for Base Realignment and Closure — is desperately needed to trim the Pentagon’s budget. The Defense Department itself has said 22 percent of its bases will be surplus by 2019, yet Congress has consistently gotten in the way, courtesy of members with military facilities in their districts. With the national debt speeding towards $20 trillion, it’s difficult to justify keeping the unneeded fat.
Are other NATO member nations freeloading off of American security guarantees? And would you demand that Western European countries spend more on defense?
According to its charter, all NATO member nations are supposed to spend at least 2 percent of their GDPs on defense. Yet last year, the United Kingdom spent only 1.9 percent, according to the World Bank, while France mustered 2.1 percent and Germany spent a pitiful 1.2 percent. Meanwhile, the United States was at 3.3 percent and Russia, a key adversary, made it to 5 percent. We’ve learned over the past 15 years that America cannot be the world’s police force: other nations must step up and rectify this imbalance.
Would you order an immediate and thorough audit of the Pentagon, in compliance with the law?
Here’s a dirty little secret: the Pentagon has been flouting the law every year since 1995. That was when it was first supposed to undergo an annual audit, according to legislation passed by Congress, yet to this day it never has. And the need is there: the military overpays for everything from fuel to health care, and its procurement system is a mess. In order for the United States to obtain the most state-of-the-art equipment and protect itself to the best of its abilities, it needs to allocate resources efficiently. Only an audit can make sure it’s doing that.