This summer, the Washington Examiner convened a symposium of the Right’s most eminent thinkers, drawn from the movement’s leading think tanks, on immigration and national identity. Like the other installments of Right Way Forward, this series featured essays from across the conservative spectrum, from Claremont Institute’s national conservatives to Cato Institute’s libertarians, with the Heritage Foundation traditionalists, Manhattan Institute reformers, and others in between.
The question at its heart wasn’t about immigration policy itself but the principle beneath it, which had sharply divided the Right throughout President Donald Trump’s second term: is America primarily a creedal nation, rooted in the ideals of the Declaration of Independence? Or is it a nation shaped by a specific cultural and civilizational inheritance?