We Must Yield ‘to the Imperative that Congress Be Free to Forge National Solutions’

Published



In a ruling released yesterday, a 3-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals didn’t void any part of Obamacare, instead ruling that the health care overhaul doesn’t clearly exceed Congress’s authority under the Commerce Clause. While concluding that Obamacare “seems an intrusive exercise of legislative power” and is “certainly is an encroachment on individual liberty,” Judge Laurence Silberman wrote, “We are obliged — and this might well be our most important consideration — to presume that acts of Congress are constitutional.” (Another judge concurred with Silberman, while a third ruled that the court did not have jurisdiction to hear the case.)

Acts of Congress should indeed be struck down only if they violate the “manifest tenor” (obvious meaning) of the Constitution — that is, if they clearly violate the Constitution, or violate it beyond a reasonable doubt.  (We should be so fortunately as to have judges adhere to this standard across the board.)  At the same time, however, there are two ways in which judges can be activist (or at least fail to do their duty):  The first is by striking down acts that don’t plainly violate the Constitution; the second is by failing to strike down acts that do. This ruling falls into the latter category.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.