BEFORE THE DUST SETTLED on the rubble that had been Abu Musab al-Zarqawi’s safe house, critics of the Bush administration were already arguing that our latest battlefield success in Iraq had to be measured against the administration’s failure to kill Zarqawi back in 2002. But a full understanding of the situation the administration faced when it had the opportunity to strike Zarqawi in 2002 shows that this was not a simple case of Bush administration blundering–even if, in hindsight, the decision was a mistake.
The background for this most recent criticism of the administration’s performance in Iraq comes from a 2004 report that appeared in the Wall Street Journal and on NBC. In 2002, the Pentagon had formulated a plan to attack Zarqawi’s operations in northern Iraq (where he had relocated after leaving Afghanistan) using cruise missiles and airstrikes. The administration didn’t give a green light to this operation. The Journal quoted the criticisms of former NSC counterterrorism director Lisa Gordon-Hagerty (“I said why didn’t we get that [‘son of a b–‘] when we could.”), while NBC reported similar remarks from former NSC member Roger Cressey.