Earlier this week, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit heard arguments in Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli’s challenge to the new healthcare law’s requirement that individuals buy health insurance, the so-called “individual mandate.” (Earlier, a trial judge strike down that requirement as unconstitutional. I earlier explained why the judge should have gone further and invalidated the whole law, since the requirement was logically inseparable from the rest of the law, and the requirement itself was unconstitutional).
The panel of appeals court judges consisted entirely of judges appointed by Democratic presidents. That was an ill-omen for Cuccinelli, since judges have split largely along party lines in their rulings on Obamacare, with judges appointed by Democrats ruling in favor of it, and judges appointed by Republicans largely voting to strike it down. The judges’ questions at oral argument were more sympathetic to the federal government’s lawyer than to the state’s lawyers.