The American Bar Association’s Phony NSA Surveillance Poll

On CBS News radio this morning, I listened to an interview with someone from the ABA who cited the results of a recent poll the group commissioned on the NSA surveillance program. You won’t be surprised to learn that the ABA poll, unlike other polls, found that a majority of Americans oppose the program. But to get these results they had to “cook the books.” The poll results were weighted for age, sex, race and geography but apparently not political affiliation/leanings. But even if one assumes the political distribution was about right, the poll questions, as you’ll see here, were misleading, to put mildly, and omitted key facts. For example, perhaps you didn’t know that the president, through the NSA program, has suspended “the constitutional freedoms of people like you.” And somehow the pollster forgot to mention the name “al Qaeda” or the fact that the program is attempting to rapidly intercept communications from an al Qaeda terrorist outside the U.S. to a person inside the U.S. You know, the situation where an al Qaeda terrorist is picked-up in Malaysia with his pockets stuffed with American phone numbers and names — or perhaps with those names and numbers on his computer hard drive. Here’s the ABA’s press release announcing the poll results:

CHICAGO, Feb.10, 2006 – According to a poll commissioned by the American Bar Association and released today, 52 percent of respondents said that in the fight against terrorism, the President of the United States alone cannot suspend constitutional freedoms, with an additional 25 percent saying he must obtain authorization by a court of law or Congress. Thus 77 percent of Americans express deep reservations about the president’s secret surveillance program…. “While everyone agrees on the need for aggressive deterrence of terrorism, the disclosure of unchecked domestic spying by the president is deeply troubling to many Americans,” said ABA President Michael S. Greco, who released the poll results today in a news conference during the ABA’s 2006 Midyear Meeting in Chicago…. Clearly, Greco said, the poll results demonstrate that Americans are deeply interested in and alarmed by issues raised by secret spying on citizens’ communications by the National Security Agency. “It is a time when we should be having conversations about our constitutional freedoms as well as our security,” he said.

Nice spin, Mr. Greco. Howard Dean couldn’t have done a better job.

Related Content