Review: Fine acting raises peaks in ‘Valley of Elah’

Published



The filmmaker behind the Oscar-winning melodrama about race in America, “Crash,” turns his unabashedly progressive socio-political point of view toward our involvement in the Iraq war with “In the Valley of Elah.” Director-writer Paul Haggis uses the crime procedural genre as the framework for his study of how destructive this particular war has been on our individual soldiers and, through them, the larger nation. It sets out to unravel the mystery of a young veteran of the conflict who disappears within days of his return home.

In so doing, it eventually intimates that this war has been somehow unique in how it has turned our baby-faced innocents from raw recruits into callous perpetrators of institutionally sanctioned atrocities who bring their irreparably damaged psyches back home to wreak havoc on the rest of us. But isn’t that what can happen in the wake of any war, not just this one? Haggis frankly proposes that the brutality and disorder coming out of Iraq is, for example, specifically worse than what came out of Vietnam. (Didn’t he ever see, say, “The Deer Hunter”?) He sometimes seems more intent on pointing fingers regarding the already unpopular Iraq war than on honing a tight narrative that works outside of the important issues it raises.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.