Our Precarious Politics

Published



The Democratic candidates, one a professed Socialist, offer a different road to fiscal disaster – more spending. There is a slight variation on the spending theme. Bernie Sanders would ramp up spending by $18 trillion in the next decade by lowering interest rates on student loans, providing free tuition in public colleges and NHS-style health care free at the point of delivery, and rebuilding the nation’s infrastructure. That would bring the federal government’s claim on the nation’s income from its historic portion of about 20 percent of GDP to a whopping 30 percent, which is a key part of the Sanders “revolution”. Hillary Clinton prefers to label her outlays “tax credits”, which have the same effect on the deficit as spending but doesn’t sound so irresponsible. She plans to provide such credits for those caring for elderly parents; to cover out-of-pocket medical costs; for businesses hiring apprentices and the unemployed “from certain target groups”, including ex-felons; for expenditures on climate-change mitigation; to help with college tuition. And more.

Sanders would squeeze the rich until the pips squeak, of which, unfortunately for him, there are an insufficient number to match his spending plans. He would raise top marginal rates to 52 percent from 39.6 percent, treat capital gains as ordinary income, and impose a tax on financial transactions, the latter known as a “Tobin tax” and believed by most economists to increase the volatility of share prices – just what we need in these days of 300-point fluctuations. Clinton would allow the Bush tax cuts on annual earnings over $250,000 to expire, sharply increase taxes on short-term capital gains, charge corporations leaving high-tax America for greener pastures an “exit fee”, and generally restore personal taxes to the levels prevailing during the prosperous years of her husband’s presidency. Both would require splashing more red ink across the national ledgers, although in Clinton’s case a few gallons less than other candidates are implicitly calling for.

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.