His long trek through more than 70 senators’ offices behind him, Judge Neil Gorsuch now comes before the Senate Committee on the Judiciary knowing at least two things for sure. First, he can expect Democratic members to offer uplifting discourses on the vital principle of judicial independence. And second, those very members will demand answers and specific commitments that, were he to oblige, would seriously compromise judicial independence. The message of the day has already been announced by progressive pressure groups: “No answers, no confirmation.”
For current members of the Supreme Court, who have been through it all themselves, it will doubtless bring back uneasy memories. Invariably during confirmation hearings, inquiries into the quality of mind and fitness of a nominee devolve into attempts to extract specific promises on matters likely to come before the Court. It’s never enough for some senators to understand a nominee’s general approach to constitutional issues. They want to know exactly how that nominee would vote on the usual issues—in effect, a solemn pledge to support and defend the liberal agenda.