Here’s a simple fact you’d never know from the media coverage of the abortion controversy inside the Republican party last week: A large majority of Republicans who voted this year chose a candidate named Dole who has never parted meaningful substantive company with the pro-life movement on the issue of abortion. Dole was selected in primary elections conducted months before a compromise on Republican platform language about abortion was ever floated. The abortion language approved last week contains pretty much the same ” compromise” pro-choice Republicans warmly welcomed when the Dole campaign initially broached the idea in early June — an expression of broad respect for Republican philosophical diversity, and nothing more.
In other words, the GOP’s platform committee deliberations left the party in pretty much the same situation it’s been in for 16 years. So why exactly are abortion-rights advocates so livid about the whole process? “I’m disappointed,” announced New York’s lieutenant governor, Betsy McCaughey. ” The opposite of tolerant is intolerant.” Others weren’t quite so dopey about it. Sen. Olympia Snowe and governors William Weld, Pete Wilson, and Christie Todd Whitman threatened for a day or two to pursue any means necessary — including a floor fight — to modulate the platform’s pro-life words. And they said they’d be doing it on behalf of . . . Bob Dole, thus echoing the conclusion of the New York Times editorial page that a majority of Republicans want “a candidate brave enough to tell the [pro-life] Family Research Council that it cannot meddle in a matter that ought to be decided privately between women and their consciences.”