Is the Supreme Court’s Abortion Decision a Victory for Kermit Gosnell?

Published



In a 5-3 decision Monday, the Supreme Court declared that a 2013 Texas statute regulating abortion clinics was unconstitutional. The Texas law, which would have established the same health and safety standards for abortion clinics as outpatient surgical centers and require a doctor on staff to have admitting privileges at a nearby hospital, was passed in the wake of the trial of Kermit Gosnell. And both the majority opinion written by Justice Breyer and a dissent written by Justice Alito addressed the case of Gosnell, the Philadelphia abortionist who was convicted of murder because he severed the spines of infants after they were born instead of legally dismembering those infants before they were born. Gosnell was also convicted of manslaughter over the death of a woman who died in his squalid clinic, which was likened to “a bad gas station restroom” by one law enforcement agent.

Alito wrote in his dissent that the Texas law could’ve stopped Gosnell and others like him: “I do not dispute the fact that [Texas’s law] H. B. 2 caused the closure of some clinics. Indeed, it seems clear that H. B. 2 was intended to force unsafe facilities to shut down. The law was one of many enacted by States in the wake of the Kermit Gosnell scandal, in which a physician who ran an abortion clinic in Philadelphia was convicted for the firstdegree murder of three infants who were born alive and for the manslaughter of a patient. Gosnell had not been actively supervised by state or local authorities or by his peers, and the Philadelphia grand jury that investigated the case recommended that the Commonwealth adopt a law requiring abortion clinics to comply with the same regulations as [ambulatory surgical centers]. If Pennsylvania had had such a requirement in force, the Gosnell facility may have been shut down before his crimes. And if there were any similarly unsafe facilities in Texas, H. B. 2 was clearly intended to put them out of business.”

Trusted reporting.Unlimited access.

Subscribe for full access to Washington Examiner coverage, expert political analysis, and subscriber-only journalism.

Get Unlimited Access

Already a member? Log in

Cancel anytime.