Last month a federal district judge in Wyoming invalidated an Interior Department rule setting stricter standards for hydraulic fracturing (“fracking,” in commin parlance) on public lands. The decision dealt a blow to the Obama administration’s environmental agenda, and news coverage focused on that. But the decision was also notable for how the judge in the case, Stephen Skavdahl, saw the law—especially since he is an Obama appointee. While you might think that an Obama judge would do the president’s bidding, or at least “defer” to the administration’s judgment, that did not happen in Wyoming v. U.S. Department of Interior.
Skavdahl said the issue in the case was whether Congress has “delegated its legal authority to the Department of Interior to regulate hydraulic fracturing.” The issue was not, he added, “whether hydraulic fracturing is good or bad for the environment or the citizens of the United States.” Hence his job: “to interpret the applicable statutory enactments and determine whether Congress has delegated” to Interior the necessary legal authority. “It has not,” he concluded.